Casemiro, Manchester United’s midfielder, was at the center of controversy during the Premier League clash against AFC Bournemouth on Sunday, as many expressed disbelief that he was not disciplined for a foul incident. United managed to claim a draw, salvaged by Rasmus Hojlund’s dramatic late goal at the Vitality Stadium, after trailing since Antoine Semenyo’s early strike in the 23rd minute.
Although the goals themselves carried no controversy, three critical incidents demanded attention. The first involved Tyler Adams’ challenge on Alejandro Garnacho. Adams received a yellow card from the referee, a decision that was reviewed by the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) but ultimately upheld after a brief delay in play.
Dermot Gallagher, a former Premier League referee, analyzed Adams’ tackle on Ref Watch. He pointed out that while Adams’ feet were briefly off the ground, the slip kept him low, and he made contact with the ball first. Gallagher judged that although the challenge bordered on dangerous, it warranted only a yellow card, emphasizing that any greater recklessness could have resulted in a red.
Another major flashpoint arose when Casemiro made contact with Bournemouth striker Evanilson, catching him with his studs in the ribs. Footage clearly showed the high impact, yet Casemiro escaped any form of punishment. Gallagher, reviewing the footage, expressed astonishment at the lack of sanction, stating the challenge clearly merited a yellow card.
Soon afterward, Evanilson found himself in trouble. He was initially booked for a heavy tackle on Noussair Mazraoui. However, following a VAR review, referee Peter Bankes upgraded the yellow card to a red, sending the Bournemouth forward off and shifting the balance of the match in United’s favor.
Despite some pundits and even Bournemouth manager Andoni Iraola arguing that Evanilson’s dismissal was overly harsh and vowing to appeal, Gallagher maintained that the red card was justified. He explained that Evanilson’s slip did not excuse the reckless nature of the tackle, as the striker drove through with his studs, creating a dangerous situation.
Gallagher emphasized that although slipping might mitigate intent, it does not remove responsibility. He argued that Evanilson’s challenge could have led to serious injury, affirming that the excessive force involved left the referee little choice but to send him off.
The Manchester Evening News remains committed to providing comprehensive coverage and thorough analysis of Manchester United’s fixtures, ensuring supporters are fully informed on the key moments that define the club’s season.
Leave a Reply